- Halacha
- General Questions
336
Question
Does orthodox Jewish consider the Book of the Macabees false? I know it is not considered a holy book, but is it’s text considered as an accurate historical account in your opinion?
Answer
The book of the Macabees is not false, rather it's considered a 'Sefer Chitzoni' (an 'external book').
Sfarim Chitzonim were written throughout early jewish history, usually discribing historical events that happend at that time period.
The holy books of the Tanach were written through prophecy or Ruach Hakodesh so we know all facts there are complete and accurate.
Sfarim Chitzonim aren't always objective, some of them are biased and selective. They are forbidden since somtimes they are influenced by religions and ideas that don't agree with the jewish spirit, and they can be a bad influence on the reader.
Rabbi Ro'i Margalit

Lying in Certain Circumstances
Rabbi Daniel Kirsch | Cheshvan 28, 5784

Sfardim Ashkenazim
Rabbi Daniel Kirsch | Cheshvan 24, 5784

Why is homosexuality forbidden in the Torah
Rabbi Ari Shvat | Av 8, 5784

BS"D or B"H on Letterhead
Rabbi Elchanan Lewis | 8 Iyyar 5765

Gifts and new clothes during the year of mourning
Rabbi Moshe Leib Halberstadt | Cheshvan 3, 5771

Light sensors on shabbos
Rabbi David Sperling | Elul 20, 5777

Induction Stove Hob
Rabbi David Sperling | Tammuz 21, 5782
