Ask the Rabbi
- Halacha
- Miscellaneous
- General Questions
Question
In Jewish law can a defendant or an accused person be a witness against himself?
If there is a prohibition on use of such confession, would this prohibition only be for non-capital (death penalty) cases?
If there is such a prohibition on the use of such a confession what is the reason behind it?
Answer
In criminal matters a person's testimony against himself or herself is invalid. The Talmudic reason is that since the testimony of a relative is invalid, any person is related to himself. The broader reason is that in Jewish law testimony may only come from objective sources. A good friend or enemy is also an invalid witness, as is a criminal.

Intermarriage
Various Rabbis | Sivan 9, 5768

Sherut Leumi - National Service
Rabbi Chaim Tabasky | 23 Elul 5766

shaving with a razor blade
Rabbi David Sperling | Elul 6, 5773




